DIY Beauty Simplified: Collagen Jelly Gel-Cream

DIY Beauty Simplified: Collagen Jelly Gel-Cream

Cayla Mandean

If you're reading this, I can tell you're curious about DIY beauty!

I've always loved it; the freedom of choosing ingredients I adore and transforming them into something uniquely mine. I started with the classics: hot oil hair treatments, nourishing cuticle and lip oils, and luxurious body oils. Oooooh, and I just loved a relaxing evening by diffusing my favourite essential oils like lavender to melt away the stress of the day. Do you see a trend here?

Yes, oils. I loved them all.

But once I discovered natural cosmetic formulation, a whole new world opened up. Oils were just the beginning. Suddenly, there were butters, oil infusions, hydrosols, botanicals, glycerites and even high-performance actives to explore.

And so, I started experimenting with creating natural body creams, face creams, toners, body scrubs, whipped shaving creams, and so much more.

What I quickly realised is that the joy of formulation isn't just in the final product; it's in the process of learning how ingredients behave, experimenting with textures, making mistakes, and finally creating something that feels amazing on the skin.

And of course, sharing those discoveries with you.

Suppose you're just starting with DIY and at-home formulation, it helps to understand the basics first, like Getting Started with DIY Cosmetics, The Importance of pH in Formulation and How to Work With Percentages.

We also have an extremely helpful Beginner-Friendly eBook that is essential for anyone new to natural cosmetic formulation.

For me, the excitement of natural cosmetic formulation comes from spotting a product or ingredient and imagining how I could bring it to life in my own way. That's exactly what happened when I first heard about collagen jelly creams.

My natural ingredient passion and writer's brain went into overdrive. The idea of a bouncy gel-cream sounded amazing, and I wanted to make my own version using marine collagen for hydration, niacinamide for its skin brightening properties, and hydroxyethyl cellulose for a unique texture. It sounded like the perfect combination of fun to make and genuinely beneficial for the skin.

When sourcing ingredients, I stick to what I know and trust. I only use products from Essentially Natural, time-tested, reliable, trusted by many and consistently high quality.

And yes, I work here, but I am always blown away by what is on offer.

Now that I know what I want to create and have found the perfect supplier for my ingredients, it's time for the best part... imagining all the exciting possibilities!

Why A Collagen Jelly Gel-Cream?

The idea of combining hydroxyethyl cellulose (HEC), niacinamide, and marine collagen is exciting from both a formulation and skin-benefit perspective.

A plant-derived, water-soluble polymer that acts as a gelling and thickening agent. It creates a clear gel with a silky, lightweight skin feel. An excellent base for the jelly-like texture I'm aiming for.

Backed by multiple studies, niacinamide improves the skin barrier, balances oil production, brightens uneven tone, and helps reduce the appearance of fine lines and hyperpigmentation. Amazing right?

Research shows 5% is an effective and well-tolerated concentration.

Provides amino acids and acts as a natural humectant, helping skin retain surface hydration, contributing to moisture retention and soft, supple skin.

Together, these ingredients create a lightweight, fast-absorbing gel-cream that hydrates without greasiness. Use it as a daily moisturiser, or apply a thicker layer as an overnight mask.

But why stop there? You can elevate your gel-cream even further! Perhaps you'd like to add hyaluronic acid for extra hydration, or a retinol alternative for anti-aging benefits. The possibilities are endless.

And it doesn't just stop at actives. You can even experiment with different gelling agents. For example, instead of hydroxyethyl cellulose (HEC), you could try xanthan gum. Why? Because different gelling agents produce different textures and skin feels, giving you full control over the sensory experience of your cream.

Now, this recipe might look a little daunting at first, but trust me - it's not as complicated as it seems. If you're still feeling a bit intimidated, check out our Guide on How to Overcome the Fear of Formulation before you dive in.

Collagen Jelly Gel-Cream Recipe

Ingredients

Phase A 

7% Eco E Wax

2% Carrier Oil of Choice (jojoba, rosehip, grapeseed, or sweet almond)

0.5% Vitamin E Oil

Phase B

3% Hydroxyethyl Cellulose (HEC)

3% Vegetable Glycerine

73% Distilled water (or Hydrosol of choice for added benefits)

Phase C 

5% Niacinamide

5% Marine Collagen

1% Geogard 221 

0.5% Essential Oil (optional – lavender, geranium, or frankincense)

Method

1. First, make the Gel Base.

  • Pre-disperse HEC in the glycerine to make a slurry and prevent clumping.
  • Gradually add water or your preferred hydrosol while stirring or blending until the gel begins to thicken.
  • Let the gel rest for 5–10 minutes.

2. While your gel base rests, you can begin to combine your Phase A ingredients. 

3. Gently heat in a double boiler until the wax melts completely. Don’t overheat (>75°C).

4. Add the niacinamide and marine collagen directly to your gel base and mix well.

5. Warm the gel base slightly so it has a similar temperature to your Phase A ingredients. (Around 70°C)

6. Slowly blend Phase A into the gel base using a stick blender or high-shear mixer until smooth. Use a blend–cool–blend cycle as it thickens, mixing intermittently while cooling.

7. Wait until it has cooled to below 40°C, then blend in the rest of your Phase C ingredients.

8. Check pH (target ~5.5 to 6 to keep niacinamide stable) and adjust if necessary.

9. Decant into a sterilised jar or pump bottle and allow your gel-cream to sit overnight so any trapped air bubbles dissipate, creating a clear, jelly-like finish.

What is Collagen Jelly Cream

Formulation Notes

  • pH Balance: Certain ingredients like Niacinamide perform best at a slightly higher pH (~6). Even if you aren’t using active ingredients, always check your product's pH for optimal ingredient efficacy and skin compatibility.
  • Scaling: Working in percentages makes it easy to scale up or down. For example, to make 50g, simply halve all amounts. (See our Guide to Using Percentages for help.)
  • Storage: Always preserve water-based products, as microbial growth can develop within days if left unprotected. Store your products in a cool, dark place to maintain their quality and longevity.
  • Hygiene: Make sure your workspace, tools, and containers are properly sanitised before you start. Clean surfaces, wash your hands, and sterilise any equipment that will come into contact with your ingredients. This helps prevent contamination and keeps your DIY products safe, effective and long-lasting.

You may be asking, “Cayla, where do I get what I need to test pH, how do I check the temperature? I don’t even have a lab!” 

Honestly, you don’t need a full professional lab to start creating your own beauty products. A basic setup at home can get you surprisingly far.  

By exploring our range of DIY Lab Equipment & Accessories, you start small and stress-free. And the best part? Your “lab” can fit right on your kitchen counter, making it easy to test ideas, tweak formulas, and watch your creations come to life.

Over time, you can gradually expand your toolkit as your formulations become more advanced or if you want to start your own beauty brand.

This is just a glimpse into my creative journey and process. If you have any tips, questions, or experiences to share, I’d love to hear them in the comments below!

Cayla Mandean

With a passion for skincare, wellness, and storytelling, Cayla is here to cut through the clutter and empower you with clear, research-backed, actionable knowledge to elevate your beauty routine and well-being. If she’s not outside in nature, at the gym, reading or spending time with her loved ones, you will find her creating clear, impactful content that inspires and informs. Her goal? To make sure you feel confident in your choices and enjoy the journey to an empowered, happier you!

Disclaimers

We love sharing DIY recipes, natural tips, and wellness inspiration with you! The content on the Essentially Natural Blog is here to inform and inspire, but it’s important to keep the following in mind as you explore:

Product Use & Medical Guidance

Unless specifically stated otherwise, our products and recipes are intended for external use only. Always follow usage instructions carefully, use ingredients mindfully, and patch test first whenever trying an ingredient/formulation for the first time. The content on our blog is shared for informational and educational purposes and is not intended to replace professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. If you’re pregnant, breastfeeding, on medication, or managing a health condition, please consult a qualified healthcare provider before using new ingredients or remedies.

Results May Vary

Natural ingredients can do wonderful things—but they’re not one-size-fits-all. What works beautifully for one person may not have the same effect for another. Your skin type, health, and lifestyle all play a role in how your body responds, so please keep that in mind. We also can’t guarantee the shelf life or stability of DIY formulations. For longer-term storage or commercial use, professional testing is always recommended

Content Accuracy

We put a lot of love and effort into making sure our content is accurate and up to date. That said, things change, and honest mistakes can happen. Please use your own good judgment and cross-check information if needed.

Third-Party Content

From time to time, we may share advice, resources, or links from third parties we trust. While we select these thoughtfully, we can’t take responsibility for their accuracy or practices—so please explore with care.

Copyright & Intellectual Property

Unless otherwise noted, all content, images, and recipes on this blog are the property of Essentially Natural. We’re always happy when our community shares and spreads the word—just please do so responsibly and with proper credit.

If you’d like more information on any ingredient or topic, feel free to reach out to us—we’re always happy to help. Alternatively, click here to view our full Terms of Service.


Thank you for being part of our natural DIY formulation community ♡